fbpx

Defective S.21 Notice – Gas Safety Certificates & Caridon Property Ltd -v- Monty Shooltz

13th February 2018 By Arman Khosravi

Property Solicitor, Property Lawyer, Housing Lawyer, Possession Lawyer, Commercial Lawyer Kensington

Welcomed by tenants and housing practitioners but perhaps a current landlord’s worst nightmare, HHJ Jan Luba QC has provided much needed clarification on the application of the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998.

In an appeal of a first instance decision of DJ Bloom, HHJ Jan Luba QC sent a highly persuasive message to housing practitioners and landlords. Although not binding as a County Court decision  (unless tested at the Court of Appeal),  landlords who did not provide a gas safety certificate at the start of a post 1st October 2015 tenancy, before the tenant moved in,  cannot now serve a valid section 21 notice, at least during the period of the tenancy.

The Law

It is S.21A of the Housing Act 1988 as (amended) which states that a S.21 notice cannot be given in relation to an AST if the landlord is in breach of the prescribed requirement.  Just some of the prescribed requirements are found in the Assured Shorthold Tenancy Notices and Prescribed Requirements (England) Regulations 2015.  By paragraph 2 (1) (b) it is prescribed that a tenant must be provided with a gas safety certificate, Paragraph 2 (2) states that the requirement to give 28 days notice does not apply but simply the requirement is to give a copy of the relevant record to the tenant.

The Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998 states at 36 (6) that “Notwithstanding paragraph (5) above, every landlord shall ensure that  –

(a) a copy of the record made pursuant to the requirements of paragraph 3(c) above is given to each existing tenant of premises to which the record relates within 28 days of the date of the check and;

(b) a copy of the last record made in respect of each appliance or flue is given to any new tenant of premises to which the record relates before the tenant occupies those premises save that, in respect of a tenant whose right to occupy those premises is for a period not exceeding 28 days, a copy of the record may instead be prominently displayed within those premises.”

Now, in HHJ Luba QC’s Judgement he explained that paragraphs 6 & 7 of Regulation 36 is only impacted in relation to notice of gas safety given to existing tenants. When referring to the 28 day period in Regulation 2 (2) andit’s wording HHJ Luba  explained: “In my Judgement, what those words mean is that where a landlord is seeking to say he or she has complied with the variant of paragraph 6 or 7 relating to an existing tenant then the 28 days period for compliance with the requirement to give notice to an existing tenant doe snot applied.”

Further HHJ Luba QC noted: “It may be observed, simply in passing that in the most recent edition of the handbook ‘Defending Possession Proceedings’- widely referred to by the first instance judiciary when dealing with possession cases, the authors of whom I am one- have written at paragraph 10.50 that “… if the latest gas safety certificate was not given to the tenant before he or she occupied, this is a breach which cannot be rectified.. although this may not have been the legislative intention.

While Caridon property Ltd v Monty Shooltz is only a County Court Appeal this decision will be treated as precedent as the Judge at first instance was a regarded Housing lawyer and at Appeal HHJ Luba QC is regarded as an eminent Housing lawyer. Since 1st October 2015 I have advocated to landlord’s and agents who instruct me that tenancy agreements must require tenants to sign for (as received) all the prescribed documents i.e. the EPC, Gas Safety Certificate, latest version of the How to Rent guide, Deposit Certificate and accompanying prescribed information.  I also advise landlords to ask tenants to sign that any Fire & Carbon Monoxide alarm has been tested as functioning in their presence. Further it is advisable (in the avoidance of dispute) that the check-in inventory and a copy of any superior lease (if advised) be exhibited to the tenancy agreement and signed for as received.

If you have any question or simply wish to find out more about Oliver Fisher’s Housing Law services then please contact Arman Khosravi on 0203 219 0145 or arman@oliverfisher.co.uk

>By Arman Khosravi dated 13th February 2018

Latest News

Tenants Can Purchase Freehold When Landlord Cannot Be Found

11th June, 2024 By

The Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 gives qualifying leaseholders the right to join together to buy the freehold of their properties – a process known as collective enfranchisement. A recent case demonstrated that this right can be exercised even when the landlord cannot be found. The leaseholders of two flats in a terraced house wished to purchase it from the landlord, but were unable to ascertain his whereabouts and therefore could not serve notice on him under Section 13 of the Act. They therefore applied for an...

Court Refuses to Set Aside Divorce Order Applied for by Mistake

6th June, 2024 By

While the courts have a range of powers to set aside orders, they will only exercise them in limited circumstances. In a somewhat surprising case that has attracted much comment, the High Court declined to set aside a final order of divorce that had been applied for by mistake. A couple separated in January 2023, after more than 21 years of marriage. In October that year, while financial remedy proceedings were still ongoing, the wife's legal representatives inadvertently applied for a final order of divorce in respect of her instead...

Waiting Time for Grants of Probate Falls

3rd June, 2024 By

Following concerns last year about delays in processing probate applications, recent figures from HM Courts and Tribunals Service show that waiting times for grants of probate are continuing to improve. The average time from submission of a probate application to probate being granted fell to 11.3 weeks in March 2024, a decrease from 13.7 weeks in February and 13.8 weeks in January. This is the lowest figure since March 2023, when the average was 10.8 weeks. The longest waiting time since then was in November, at 15.8 weeks: that month,...

Late Appeal Against Tax Penalties Rejected

31st May, 2024 By

It is incumbent on taxpayers to make sure they fully comply with their obligations to file returns and pay any tax due. The point was illustrated by a recent case in which a taxpayer whose return had not been received by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) failed to persuade the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) that he should be permitted to appeal against the resulting penalties. On the evening of 31 January 2014, the man had completed his 2012/13 Income Tax return on HMRC's website. Shortly afterwards he went to Cyprus, and...