fbpx

Giving With Warm Hands to Minimise Inheritance Tax – High Court Ruling

9th September 2020 By

The most straightforward means of minimising Inheritance Tax (IHT) payable on your estate is to give away your assets with warm hands when you are still hale and hearty. However, such gifts will bring no tax advantages at all unless they are absolute and unreserved.

A recent High Court case concerned four British Virgin Islands-based trusts which were set up by a wealthy British businessman to hold various UK properties for the benefit of his two sons, their spouses and progeny. The objective of the trusts was to remove the properties from the businessman’s estate for IHT purposes.

He and his wife were not included amongst the class of beneficiaries of the trusts. Due to a drafting error, however, they were not specifically excluded from that class, which the trustees enjoyed wide powers to expand. That gave rise to concerns that HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) might take the view that the businessman had reserved a benefit in the trusts. Such a conclusion would frustrate their objective and render the entire tax planning arrangement ineffective.

In coming to the businessman’s aid, the Court noted that he was in his late 70s and suffering from Parkinson’s disease and dementia. As he lacked the mental capacity required to make important decisions for himself, his wife had launched proceedings on his behalf, seeking rectification of the drafting error.

Ruling on the matter, the Court noted that the businessman’s intention had been to provide for his sons and future generations of his family in a tax-efficient way. He and his wife had behaved throughout in a manner entirely consistent with an intention to exclude themselves from receiving any benefit under the trusts. They were scrupulous about not staying at any of the trust properties.

The Court found convincing proof that a mistake had been made, as a result of which the trusts, as drafted, did not accurately reflect the businessman’s intentions. The understanding of all involved had been that the trusts would result in the properties passing outside of his estate. To secure that objective, the Court rectified the trusts so as to expressly exclude the businessman, his wife and any future spouses of his from the class of beneficiaries.

Source: Concious

Latest News

Don't Even Consider a Foreign Adoption Without Specialist Legal Advice

23rd September, 2020 By

Adopting children from abroad can complete families and be of great benefit to all concerned. However, as a High Court case showed, it is fraught with legal pitfalls and should not be attempted without first taking specialist legal advice. The case concerned a British citizen who adopted a child in Iran under Iranian law. The child had thrived in the adoptive placement. The parent launched proceedings in London, seeking recognition of the adoption in this country. The Home Office opposed the application on the basis that the criteria for recognition...

Property Investors – Make Sure Your Money is Secured From the Outset

17th September, 2020 By

Investing in property is very far from being risk free but usually has the advantage that monies advanced are secured against real 'bricks and mortar' assets. The crucial importance of ensuring that enforceable security is in place before parting with your money was underlined by a High Court ruling. The case concerned a company's purchase of a substantial property with a view to its conversion into a nursing home. Private investors were sought on the basis that they would be granted leases of individual rooms. More than 50 investors, who...

Family Dispute Underlines Wisdom of Making a Professionally Drafted Will

14th September, 2020 By

Family disputes frequently focus on inheritance and can inflict immense anxiety and pain on all concerned. A case concerning a young man who died tragically when he stepped in front of a train, however, showed that the best way to avoid such conflict is to make a professionally drafted will. The deceased, who had learning disabilities and mental health issues, was aged just 35 when he died but was a wealthy man due to an inheritance from his grandfather. An inquest resulted in a verdict of accidental death. Following his...

International Child Abduction | in Hague Convention cases you need a specialist solicitor

9th September, 2020 By Beatrice B Bray

Santosh Kumar has over 25 years’ experience handling international child abduction cases. Here Ms Kumar explains why having a specialist solicitor is vital to getting a positive outcome with child abductions, particularly in Hague Convention cases. Background to the case I recently took over a child abduction case from a firm who had little understanding of Hague Convention cases. The client had come to me because she understood the case was not going well. What she could not have known is that her previous firm had not set out any defence...