Court Agrees to Correct Trust Error

26th October 2018 By Alireza Nurbakhsh

We all make mistakes…and when a contract is set up the terms of which clearly do not reflect what was intended, the court can be asked to rectify it. A recent case shows that that approach can also be taken with regard to incorrectly drafted trust documents.

When a couple wrote their wills, they provided that on death a family trust was to be set up. This was part of an Inheritance Tax (IHT) mitigation exercise. When the wife died, the family home was transferred into the trust, with the husband as the beneficial owner of a half share in the property and their two daughters entitled to a quarter share each in it.

The potential beneficiaries of the trust included the settlors, who included the two daughters. The trust deed allowed the trustees to apply the trust fund for the benefit of any of the beneficiaries.

Regrettably, a later clause in the trust deed specifically prevented the settlors from benefiting from it – a clear drafting error. The apparent position was made worse by the addition of a clause that meant if the trust ‘failed’ for any reason, the trust assets would be given to charity.

The rectification of the drafting required a visit to court, and although the family were all happy for the trust deed to be amended, the judge did have to consider the potential implications for a future spouse or any children of the settlors, as the trust deed made them a ‘contingent gift’.

In a judgment that ran to 36 paragraphs, the High Court ruled that the clause which prevented ‘any part of the trust income or capital’ to be applied for the benefit of a settlor was to be ruled void.

Source: Concious

Latest News

Motor Insurers Not Liable for £2 Million Fire Damage

27th June, 2019 By Alireza Nurbakhsh

The law requires that the driver of any vehicle has a valid insurance policy that covers injury or damage to third parties caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle on a road or in a public place. The Supreme Court has given authoritative guidance on the meaning of that phrase in a case of crucial importance to vehicle owners and the insurance industry. The case concerned an employee of an engineering firm, the owners of which allowed him to use the premises to do work on...

Ignore Court Orders At Your Peril

24th June, 2019 By Alireza Nurbakhsh

A wealthy Omani man who failed to pay to his ex-wife the financial settlement ordered by the court, or to cooperate with disclosure orders, faces arrest if he attempts to return to the UK. When the couple's marriage broke up, they were divorced under Omani law. However, the wife, a resident of the UK, sought and obtained orders in the UK court for financial relief (under Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984) for herself and their children, who live with her. The divorce took place in 2017...

Failure to Challenge Repaving Results in Loss of Title

20th June, 2019 By Alireza Nurbakhsh

Failing to take active steps to protect your land from use by another can produce unfortunate effects, as a couple from York discovered recently. The couple own a bungalow which has a front driveway adjacent to that of the next-door bungalow – a common design. The two effectively blend into one before reaching the road. In 1986 their neighbour repaved her drive with new paving tiles and brick edging, and in so doing went across the boundary line between the two properties. She parked her car on the area and...

Just Because You Agree Doesn't Mean the Court Will

18th June, 2019 By Alireza Nurbakhsh

It is common in legal disputes for the two sides to agree to suspend the court proceedings for a period so that they can get as much agreed between them as possible, and gather their evidence and prepare their arguments over what remains in dispute without the pressure of an impending hearing date. Such an agreement is called a 'standstill agreement', and if proceedings are served in time it is usual for the court to agree to the requested hiatus. In a recent family law case, one of the UK's...